Teddy Bridgewater and beyond: Backup QB rankings


11 to 13. Kenny Pickett, Pittsburgh Steelers
Desmond Ridder, Atlanta Falcons
Malik Willis, Tennessee Titans

Pickett’s common preseason cross may greatest be measured in air centimeters, however he did exhibit a capability to run the offense effectively in hurry-up situations. Ridder appeared promising all through the preseason, although a few of his highlights (like his game-winning landing within the preseason opener) would flip into bloopers in opposition to actual NFL competitors. Willis produced a number of scattered viral highlights however appeared typically extraordinarily unready by 51 cross makes an attempt and 9 sacks in three video games.

The order above is each alphabetical and intentional, with Pickett most able to game-manage his method to a win or two due to his supporting forged, Willis able to probably shocking a Jaguars/Texans degree opponent together with his arm and wheels, and Ridder someplace in between. All three stay viable quarterbacks of assorted futures, however that is the place B-tier prospects inevitably land as rookies: They’re scholar drivers, and their coordinators might want to hold a foot on the brakes always if they’re pressured to start out.

14. Case Keenum, Buffalo Payments

Welcome to the kelp forest of creaky veterans!

Keenum led the Browns to 2 victories in 2021: the Thursday night time D’Ernest Johnson goes HAM 17-14 win over the Broncos and a Week 18 custodial job in opposition to the Bengals backups. He led Washington to a 1-7 file in 2019, with 24-3, 9-0 and 19-9 losses. It is tempting to lump Keenum among the many Foles/Dalton varieties due to his 2017 success, however he is not less than a full rung beneath them. That stated, he exhibits up able to play and may lead the Payments to a spot-start win or two in opposition to second-tier opponents.

15. Colt McCoy, Arizona Cardinals

McCoy led the Cardinals to 2 victories in aid of Kyler Murray final season, with an unpleasant 34-10 loss to the Panthers led by the P.J. Walker/Cam Newton platoon in between. So is he ranked too low right here? Under no circumstances. The Cardinals’ second win with McCoy on the helm got here in opposition to the Seahawks quickly after Wilson rushed again too quickly from his hand damage. The Seahawks held the ball for simply 19 minutes and 38 seconds. McCoy fumbled 3 times, however the Cardinals recovered all of them. He spent many of the sport dripping micropasses to Rondale Moore and James Conner in a 23-13 victory, so it wasn’t precisely a repeatable method for achievement. Every little thing else about McCoy’s 12-year profession—most notably how not often he ever received right into a sport—means that he actually ought to be teaching within the Massive 12 by now.

16. Tyrod Taylor, New York Giants

Theoretical Tyrod Taylor is a “makes issues occur” backup with wheels, gobs of expertise and a popularity for caring for the soccer in any respect prices that coaches recognize. Precise Tyrod Taylor tends to just do what he did within the preseason: common round 5.4 yards per try for a sport or so (with extra turnovers than anticipated) earlier than getting injured himself.

17. Joe Flacco, New York Jets

Flacco, like Keenum or McCoy, initially appears to be like like a Foles-level backup, however Flacco’s groups are 2-11 in his final 11 begins relationship again to the 2019 Broncos. And, nicely, you have seen him play. Like Keenum, Flacco may lead the Payments previous an opponent just like the Jets. Sadly, Flacco performs for the Jets.

18. Blaine Gabbert, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Gabbert is loads like Geno Smith: a toolsy failed prospect from 2011 who discovered a candy gig hiding on the bench behind a sturdy famous person. Like Geno, Gabbert would most likely dink, dunk and scramble his method to modest success in a short aid look. Not like Geno, we’ve not seen Gabbert do a lot of something since he backed up Marcus Mariota for the 2018 Titans. He goes right here as a result of he cannot actually be positioned any greater, and it feels a little bit mean-spirited to position him decrease.

19. Sam Darnold or P.J. Walker, Carolina Panthers

Darnold was not too long ago a bottom-rung starter, making it tempting to listing him among the many prime backups. Nonetheless, there is a degree of unflappability that comes with being a top quality backup, and Darnold has been extremely flappable all through his younger profession. Prime prospects equivalent to Darnold not often morph into high quality profession backups. If a quarterback falls from “quarterback of the longer term” to “flunked his second probability” in 4 years, he is most likely destined to change into Blake Bortles/Jake Locker/Joey Harrington/Tim Sofa, not Vinny Testaverde, Kerry Collins and even Gabbert.

Walker, in the meantime, has a popularity as a “makes issues occur” backup however a knack for interception sprees off the bench. Each Darnold and Walker are as more likely to exacerbate a disaster as mitigate one.

20. Nick Mullens, Minnesota Vikings

He is the arithmetic imply of Case Keenum and C.J. Beathard, the best emergency quarterback if everybody else has COVID/accidents/jury obligation and the backup the Vikings are caught with as a result of the Kellen Mond/Sean Mannion competitors resulted in a double-TKO.

21. Chad Henne, Kansas Metropolis Chiefs

“Get you thru exactly two sequence on the finish of a playoff sport” ought to be its personal class.

22. Trevor Siemian, Chicago Bears

When Walkthrough first got here up with these backup quarterback rankings, it gave the impression of a fantastic concept. I can burn some leftover Minshew and Tua jokes and knock the entire thing out on Friday, then hit the pool for the weekend!

Then I reached this second, the second the place I needed to discover one thing related to write down about Trevor Siemian, and I spotted that I used to be in hell. I had consigned my immortal soul to hell. To not chase wine, ladies and music, thoughts you, however within the title of a straightforward byline. What circle of hell is that this, Dante? The one the place Devil makes use of Brutus and Cassius as suppositories? Eh, I got here to this destiny actually.

Anyway, Siemian began a bunch of video games for a Saints group with a fantastic protection and a strong offensive line however no playmakers final yr, giving method to Taysom Hill for a number of Wildcat junkballs per sport. The Saints fell nicely behind the Titans, Eagles and even the Falcons in three of these video games, just for Siemian to throw some late touchdowns to make the ultimate rating shut. The Payments stated “LOLZ, nope” to that routine with a Thanksgiving basting, after which it was formally (sigh) Taysom time.

If you’re searching for a quarterback to get you thru a month of backdoor covers, Siemian would possibly certainly be your man.

23. Brian Hoyer, New England Patriots

Hoyer’s groups are 1-12 in his spot begins relationship again to 2016. The Patriots’ 2022 outlook can be a lot better if Bailey Zappe had been Mac Jones’ backup and Hoyer was the offensive coordinator.

24. Chase Daniel, Los Angeles Chargers

The Mario Mendoza of veteran backups. In case your journeyman mentor one way or the other has much less sport expertise or a better wage than Daniel, it is time to dump him for some league-minimum rando.

Backup Quarterbacks Who Simply Get You Beneath the Cap

Source link